Redbird Daily’s 100 Greatest Cardinals: #2 – Stan Musial

This series was originally published at the Redbird Daily, but is now proud to call Cards Conclave home. This installment was written by Colin Garner.

If you haven’t, check out the Introductory Article to to gain understanding of how these rankings were built. That article can be found by clicking here.

Without further ado, I present…

2. Stan Musial – 1B/LF (1941-1944, 1946-1963, 24x All-Star, 7x Batting Title, 3x MVP, HOF)

Standard Batting
22 Y 22 Y 22 Y 22 Y 3026 12718 10972 1949 3630 725 177 475 1951 78 31 1599 696 .331 .417 .559 .976 159 6134 53 127
Provided by View Original Table
Generated 2/1/2018.

There’s nothing that hasn’t been said about Stan ‘The Man’ Musial. He is the qinitessential Cardinal, the best player in franchise history, and one of the most respected athletes in American professional sports history. During his career, the Cardinals were succesful: they won three World Series titles and another National League pennant. When he retired in 1963, he held 17 Major League records, 29 National League records, and nine All-Star Game records.

Yet, everywhere but St. Louis, for some reason, Musial isn’t mentioned along with DiMaggio, Mays, Mantle, and Robinson.

A three-time MVP record twenty-four-time All-Star, Musial’s Baseball-Reference page is littered with bold-faced type indicating that he led the league in that particular category in that particular year. He led the National League in games played four times, runs five times, hits six times, doubles eight times, triples five times, RBI’s twice, batting average seven times, on-base percentage six times, slugging percentage six times, OPS seven times, OPS+ six times, and total bases six times.

Joe Posnanski told a story on his bog that captures the skill of Musial the ballplayer and the character of Musial the person.

There was this game, early in ’54, the year that Edward Murrow went after Joe McCarthy and Roger Bannister ran a mile in four minutes, and Musial’s Cardinals trailed the Chicago Cubs 3-0 in the seventh inning. Cubs lefty pitcher Paul Minner was baffling the Cardinals — he had allowed just two singles, had faced one over the minimum. Then he found himself facing Musial with Wally Moon was on first base and two outs.
Musial crushed a ball to deep right field, a double. Moon ran all the around the bases to score. Musial cruised into second. The whole complexion of the game had changed. And it was only then that everyone seemed to notice the first base umpire, Lee Ballanfant, was holding up his arms. He had called Musial’s double a foul ball.
Nobody quite knew how to react. The ball, at least in the Cardinals’ view, had clearly been fair. It was not even an especially close call. And while the crowd cheered wildly (the game was in Chicago) the guys on the Cardinals bench went crazy. They rushed on the field, shortstop Solly Hemus first, manager Eddie Stanky right behind him, and both were thrown out by home plate umpire Augie Donatelli. Old Augie Donatelli. He would play a big role in Musial’s life. Donatelli would be one of the umpires there less than a month later when Musial hit five homers in a doubleheader. Much later, he was behind the plate for Musial’s 3,000th hit. Anyway, he was here now, taking away a Musial hit, throwing out Hemus and Stanky, threatening pinch hitter Peanuts Lowrey with ejection, clearing the saloon like an old cowboy, even though, he certainly knew, the ball had been fair.
Musial, who in the confusion had not been told exactly what was going on, walked over to Donatelli. Then, according to the stories, he calmly asked, “What happened Augie? It didn’t count, huh?” Augie nodded sadly and said the umpire had called the ball foul.
“Well,” Musial said, “there’s nothing you can do about it.”
Stan Musial stepped back promptly doubled to precisely the same spot in right field. This time, Ballanfant called the ball fair. The Cardinals scored six runs in the inning and won the game.

At his funeral in 2013, Musial was eulogized by the great St. Louisan, Bob Costas. Costas told a story about when, after the Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier, the Cardinals faced the Dodgers who started Joe Black, an African-American pitcher. Racial slurs and taunts emanated from the Cardinals dugout while Musial was at-bat. After the game, Musial saw Black in the tunnel. According to Costas, he said “I’m sorry you had to hear that. You’re a great pitcher who will have a fine career.”

The stories that filled Costas’ eulogy that day are testament to the fact that Stan was, in Costas’ words, a thoroughly decent human being. The entire eulogy is below, which I highly suggest watching.

Musial finished his career the same way he started it: a two-for-three day. He finished with an impeccable record of consistency that included 1,815 hits at home and 1,815 hits on the road, the grand total of 3,630 standing as the National League record until Pete Rose broke it in 1981.

Musial still holds several records, including:

  • 24 All-Star Game Appearances, 6 All-Star Game home runs
  • Most years batting over .300 (17), most consecutive years batting over .300 (16)
  • 22 seasons with the Cardinals, the most with one club National League history
  • Most seasons leading the league in doubles (7) and extra-base hits (6)
  • Most home runs in a double header (5)

Baseball’s perfect warrior, baseball’s perfect knight.

Thanks for reading!

Colin Garner

Series Navigation<< Redbird Daily’s 100 Greatest Cardinals: #3 – Bob GibsonRedbird Daily’s 100 Greatest Cardinals: #1 – Albert Pujols >>

Next Post:

Previous Post:

Please share, follow, or like us :)

Subscribe to The Conclave via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 16.3K other subscribers



Other posts in this series: