How Would You Set Up The Rotation?

With nothing else to do, let’s do a little group thinking, shall we?

When the Cardinals lost Lance Lynn for the year due to Tommy John surgery, they eventually picked up Mike Leake to fill that void.  However, few of us immediately slotted Leake into Lynn’s spot in the rotation.  Lynn was set up as the #2 starter in 2015 (though there are questions about whether he’d have been there again this season if he was healthy) but Leake, at least in my mind, always sat at the end of the rotation.

That’s nothing against the newest Cardinal, not at all.  It’s just that this rotation is a talented one, one that put up some historic numbers last year with minimal contribution from the staff ace.  Leake might be a mid-rotation guy for a lot of teams, but he didn’t seem to be one on this squad.

Then I saw some Twitter exchanges with Derrick Goold about where Leake fit in the rotation and Goold questioned (obliquely, at least) whether Leake really was a #5 guy.  On talent, I think he’d rank well behind any of the four that are already on staff, but talent is not always the only factor taken into account when setting up a rotation.

For instance, maybe you put Leake in the third spot with Carlos Martinez and Michael Wacha after him, figuring that the end of the rotation might get a start or two less and that keeps the young guys’ inning count low.  Perhaps you mix the styles of the pitchers, so that the hard-throwing Martinez is followed by Leake who is followed by the nasty stuff of Jaime Garcia.

So how would you order the staff 1-5 this season?  Well, let’s say 2-5, because I’m going to assume that everyone is going to put Adam Wainwright as the staff ace and the guy pitching on Opening Day.  The other four, though, could be set up in a myriad of different ways.  I want your opinion–tell me who should be 2, 3, 4, and 5 when the season begins in a couple of months.  We’ll talk about the answers (and perhaps look at the bullpen in a similar way) in an upcoming post.  Be sure to scroll down and answer all four questions.

(Also, while I have you, don’t forget about the Cardinal Approval Ratings!)

Create your own user feedback survey

  • plm998877 February 10, 2016, 10:17 am

    Can we assume that the approval ratings will be posted on 2/22?
    If Cooney AND Gonzales don’t impress at ST….. it’s a long way down to Weaver and Poncedeleon at AA in ’16. I don’t think Reyes will be ready in ’16 after his suspension plus things get real dicey if he has another violation.

    • Cardinal70 February 10, 2016, 10:24 am

      Historically I’ve spread out the approval ratings over the span of some regular posts. Usually three a day (and assuming I remember them!) at the end of whatever else we are talking about at that time. Probably start that around the 22nd, though, for sure.

      You’ve got Lyons, Cooney and Gonzales. I think at least one of those guys will be ready for a fill in, if necessary. Now, if you are talking about months to fill in, that may be a different story and one that requires a move. For general depth, though, I think those guys will be fine. You are right, Reyes isn’t in the 2016 picture–earliest I can see him is a September bullpen role, but even that’s iffy.

Next Post:

Previous Post:

Please share, follow, or like us :)

Subscribe to The Conclave via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 16,261 other subscribers

NL Central Standings

Cardinals9369.574 -

Last updated: 10/06/2022